What You Feel. Pure Freedom

11 January 2006

WYF Philosophy:

Our minds cannot fathom concepts that don't already exist.

Verdad o Mentira?

7 comments:

Anonymous said...

what?

Uteng said...

anonymous did well not to add a name with that rather daft remark.
I agree with the fact that there are timeless archetypes of all things cassubian. I think there are certain things people have always been fixated on as far back as our historical knowledge takes us- some of it Must be real!

miku said...

why is his remark daft?

miku said...

damn! the page never finished loading so i didnt see common guy's before i added mine...well said guy (or rather well done for quoting something relevent that someone else said)

this blog is far too pretentious for its own good.

but, using something that you adhered to from te bible:
"solomon's" saying that 'there is nothing new under the sun' is rendered untrue if the mind can fathom things that doesn't exist. The argument is everything is in existence already. whether its been discovered or not is another thing.

Anonymous said...

Yes mimi..work it out..feelin your flo. Common Guy..you are the man.


'Technical language can often confuse people. That and also bullshit!!!'

That last line is the killer. I love this blog.

I think the question is unclear. The definitionn of a concept as I understand it is 'a thought or notion.' Basically a concept is an idea.

How can you even come to the point of struggling to understand a concept if it hasn't already been formulated into existence.

I think uteng needs to enlighten me here. I am confused.

Uteng said...

ok, fathom was a slightly misleading term. a better word would be...'conceive' or 'envision'. Happy?

Anonymous said...

yeah ok..in which case I concur with mimi's statement. Assuming that there can be nothing new in this world, then the mind can only ever consider concepts that already exist.

However, as mimi implied, it would be foolhardy to interpret that verse;

(Ecclesiastes 1:9-10 NIV) What has been will be again, what has been done will be done again; there is nothing new under the sun. {10} Is there anything of which one can say, "Look! This is something new"? It was here already, long ago; it was here before our time.

..as meaning that human beings cannot discover concepts for the first time. So ultimately I have to ask Uteng if he is asking whether a)human beings can discover concepts or b)create them. The latter is not in keeping with Ecclesiastes 1:9.